What Is Identity?

N

Table of Contents

What Is Identity? Everything You Need to Know

Have you ever stopped to consider what makes you, you? What is identity, and how does it shape everything from our personal relationships to our cultural values and even our political beliefs? In today’s rapidly evolving world, understanding what is identity is more important than ever. From the intricate interplay of genetics, experiences, and social influences to the digital personas we cultivate online, identity forms the core of who we are. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the concept of identity in depth—from its definition and key characteristics to its historical evolution, real-world applications, and modern relevance. Whether you’re a student, educator, writer, or simply a curious mind, this article will provide you with all the insights you need about what is identity and why it matters.


Introduction: The Core of Who We Are

Imagine waking up each day with a clear understanding of your own unique identity—a deep awareness of your values, beliefs, experiences, and aspirations. Now, consider that this very concept influences how you interact with the world, form relationships, and even make decisions. Did you know that social scientists have long debated the nature of identity, suggesting that it is not fixed but continually evolving based on our interactions, environments, and experiences? This fascinating subject lies at the intersection of psychology, sociology, philosophy, and even biology.

In this article, we will cover:

  • A clear definition of identity and its core components.
  • The essential characteristics that define what identity is, including personal, social, cultural, and digital dimensions.
  • A historical and contextual background outlining the evolution of identity—from ancient philosophical debates to modern identity politics.
  • An in-depth exploration of the various facets of identity, including theories of identity development and the role of intersectionality.
  • Real-world examples and case studies that illustrate how identity is applied and observed in everyday life, society, and various professional fields.
  • The importance, applications, and benefits of understanding identity in personal growth, education, business, and cultural development.
  • Common misconceptions and FAQs to address myths and clarify misunderstandings about identity.
  • Modern relevance and current trends, including how digital technology, social media, and globalization are reshaping our understanding of identity.
  • A conclusion that summarizes the key points and offers a call-to-action for further exploration, discussion, and engagement.

By the end of this guide, you will have a thorough understanding of what is identity, appreciate its complex nature, and be empowered to apply this knowledge to enhance your personal, professional, and social life. Let’s embark on this journey to uncover the essence of who we are.


Section 1: Defining Identity

What Is Identity?

At its most basic level, identity refers to the qualities, beliefs, personality traits, and expressions that make a person or group distinct. It encompasses both internal factors—such as personal values, experiences, and emotions—and external factors, including social roles, cultural background, and community affiliations.

Straightforward Definition:
Identity is the unique combination of characteristics, beliefs, and values that defines an individual or group. It is both a personal and social construct, shaped by internal self-perception as well as external influences and interactions.

Essential Characteristics of Identity

When we ask what is identity, several key characteristics emerge:

  • Multidimensionality:
    Identity is not a single trait but a mosaic of factors including personality, culture, gender, ethnicity, nationality, and more. It is a dynamic and multifaceted construct.

  • Dynamic and Evolving:
    Identity is not fixed; it changes over time as individuals encounter new experiences, challenges, and social contexts. Life events such as education, relationships, and career changes all contribute to its evolution.

  • Internal and External Components:
    There is a personal, introspective aspect of identity—how we see ourselves—and a social component—how others perceive and interact with us. Both are crucial in forming a complete sense of self.

  • Cultural and Social Influence:
    Cultural background, societal norms, and community values heavily influence our identity. From language and traditions to social expectations, these external factors play a significant role in shaping who we are.

  • Interconnectedness:
    Identity often intersects with other aspects such as social class, religion, and political affiliation. This concept, known as intersectionality, highlights how overlapping social identities can compound experiences of privilege or disadvantage.

Understanding these characteristics is fundamental for delving deeper into the concept of identity and appreciating its profound impact on our lives.


Section 2: Historical and Contextual Background

The Evolution of Identity

The exploration of what is identity has deep roots in human thought. Throughout history, scholars, philosophers, and theologians have pondered the nature of identity, seeking to understand what truly defines a person or a group.

Ancient Philosophical Perspectives

  • Classical Antiquity:
    Ancient Greek philosophers like Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle explored ideas of self-knowledge and personal virtue. Plato’s allegory of the cave, for example, is a metaphor for the journey toward understanding one’s true self.

  • Eastern Philosophies:
    In Eastern traditions, such as Buddhism and Hinduism, identity is often seen as fluid and interconnected. Buddhist teachings emphasize the concept of “no-self” (anatta), suggesting that clinging to a fixed identity can be a source of suffering. Hindu philosophy, on the other hand, explores the idea of the self (atman) as a reflection of the universal spirit (Brahman).

Medieval and Renaissance Views

  • Medieval Theology:
    During the Medieval period, identity was closely linked to religious and moral beliefs. Christian thinkers like St. Augustine and Thomas Aquinas considered the human soul and its relationship to God as central to one’s identity.

  • Renaissance Humanism:
    The Renaissance shifted focus toward individualism and self-expression. Artists, writers, and scholars began to explore human identity through art, literature, and science, laying the groundwork for modern notions of personal identity.

Modern Perspectives on Identity

  • Psychological Theories:
    In the 20th century, psychologists such as Erik Erikson and James Marcia developed theories of identity formation, emphasizing the importance of social and developmental factors. Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development, for example, highlight identity formation as a key challenge during adolescence.

  • Sociological and Cultural Approaches:
    Sociologists have examined how social structures, cultural narratives, and group memberships contribute to identity. The concept of intersectionality, introduced by Kimberlé Crenshaw, has further enriched our understanding by demonstrating how various social identities intersect to shape experiences and opportunities.

  • Digital Age and Identity:
    The rise of the internet and social media has added a new dimension to identity. Today, many individuals cultivate online personas that may differ from their offline identities. This digital duality has sparked debates about authenticity and the impact of technology on self-perception.

Notable Historical Anecdotes

  • Socrates and the Quest for Self-Knowledge:
    The famous dictum “Know thyself” from ancient Greek philosophy underscores the timeless quest to understand one’s identity. This pursuit laid the philosophical groundwork for later discussions on what constitutes a person’s true self.

  • Erikson’s Stages of Development:
    Erik Erikson’s influential theory on identity formation during adolescence has shaped modern psychology. His work illustrates how identity is continuously shaped by our experiences and social interactions.

  • The Digital Transformation:
    The emergence of social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram has transformed our understanding of identity. These platforms have become virtual spaces where individuals experiment with and express different facets of their identity.

For further historical context, resources such as the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and Psychology Today offer in-depth explorations of identity theory and its evolution.


Section 3: In-Depth Exploration of Identity

To truly understand what is identity, we must delve into its various dimensions. In this section, we will break down the concept into its core components, examine different categories of identity, and explore how identity manifests in various contexts.

Categories of Identity

Identity can be broadly categorized into several types, each contributing uniquely to our overall sense of self.

1. Personal Identity

  • Definition:
    Personal identity refers to the unique characteristics, experiences, values, and beliefs that define an individual. It encompasses our personality traits, memories, and the narrative we construct about our lives.

  • Key Elements:

    • Self-Concept: How we perceive ourselves (our strengths, weaknesses, and personality).
    • Self-Esteem: How we value ourselves.
    • Life Narrative: The story we tell ourselves about our past, present, and future.
  • Real-World Example:
    Consider how a person’s journey of overcoming adversity becomes a core part of their personal identity, shaping their outlook and resilience.

2. Social Identity

  • Definition:
    Social identity is derived from the groups to which we belong, such as our family, ethnicity, gender, religion, and social class. It reflects how we see ourselves in relation to others.

  • Key Elements:

    • Group Membership: The communities and groups that influence our identity.
    • Social Roles: The roles we play within these groups (e.g., parent, student, employee).
    • Cultural Norms: Shared values and traditions that shape our behavior and beliefs.
  • Real-World Example:
    A person might identify strongly with their cultural heritage, participating in traditions and community events that reinforce their sense of belonging.

3. Cultural and National Identity

  • Definition:
    Cultural identity refers to the beliefs, customs, and values that define a particular culture, while national identity is the sense of belonging to a specific nation or state.

  • Key Elements:

    • Traditions and Practices: Cultural rituals, language, and art that create a sense of shared history.
    • Symbols and Icons: Flags, anthems, and monuments that evoke national pride.
    • Historical Narratives: Collective memories that shape a nation’s identity.
  • Real-World Example:
    National holidays and cultural festivals, such as Independence Day in the United States or Diwali in India, play a significant role in reinforcing cultural and national identities.

4. Digital Identity

  • Definition:
    Digital identity is the online persona that individuals create through social media, blogs, and other digital platforms. It can be an extension of one’s personal and social identities or a separate construct altogether.

  • Key Elements:

    • Online Presence: Social media profiles, digital content, and virtual interactions.
    • Anonymity and Authenticity: The balance between genuine self-expression and curated online images.
    • Interactivity: The dynamic nature of digital identity, shaped by real-time feedback and engagement.
  • Real-World Example:
    Influencers on platforms like Instagram or YouTube often craft a digital identity that may blend aspects of their true selves with an idealized version, affecting both their public perception and personal self-concept.

The Process of Identity Formation

Understanding what is identity also requires an exploration of how identity is formed and evolves over time. This process is influenced by both internal factors (like personality and self-reflection) and external factors (such as culture, relationships, and life experiences).

Theories of Identity Formation

  • Erikson’s Psychosocial Development:
    Erik Erikson’s theory suggests that identity formation is a lifelong process, with adolescence being a critical period. His concept of identity versus role confusion highlights the challenges individuals face in establishing a coherent sense of self.

  • Social Identity Theory:
    This theory, developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner, explains how group memberships and social interactions shape our self-concept and behavior. It emphasizes the importance of in-group versus out-group dynamics in forming social identity.

  • Narrative Identity:
    Narrative identity focuses on the stories we construct about our lives. These personal narratives integrate our past experiences, present circumstances, and future aspirations, forming a coherent sense of who we are.

  • Intersectionality:
    Coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, intersectionality examines how various aspects of identity (such as race, gender, class, and sexuality) interact to create a complex, multifaceted identity that cannot be understood by looking at one aspect in isolation.

Real-World Examples and Case Studies

Example 1: Personal Transformation Through Life Narratives

Consider an individual who has overcome significant adversity—such as surviving a serious illness or overcoming poverty. Their personal narrative, which highlights resilience and growth, becomes a core part of their identity. This self-defined narrative not only shapes how they view themselves but also influences how others perceive and interact with them.

Example 2: The Role of Cultural Identity in Social Movements

Cultural and national identities have played pivotal roles in numerous social movements around the world. For example, the civil rights movement in the United States was deeply rooted in the African American identity, which was celebrated and affirmed as a source of strength and resistance. This collective identity galvanized communities, leading to transformative social and political change.

Example 3: Digital Identity in the Age of Social Media

The rise of digital technology has given birth to a new dimension of identity. Consider how social media influencers carefully craft their online personas to appeal to specific audiences. Their digital identity may incorporate elements of their real-life personality while also being shaped by trends, algorithms, and audience feedback. This evolving digital identity demonstrates the fluid nature of identity in the modern age.

For further exploration of identity formation, resources such as Psychology Today and the American Psychological Association (APA) provide insightful articles and research findings.


Section 4: Importance, Applications, and Benefits of Understanding Identity

The Significance of Identity in Everyday Life

Understanding what is identity is crucial because it influences every aspect of our lives—our relationships, career choices, political views, and even our mental health. Here’s why identity matters:

Personal Empowerment

  • Self-Awareness and Growth:
    A clear understanding of your own identity empowers you to make decisions that align with your values, aspirations, and true self. Self-awareness fosters personal growth and helps you navigate life’s challenges with confidence.

  • Resilience and Adaptability:
    A strong sense of identity can provide stability during times of change or adversity. It serves as a foundation for resilience, allowing you to adapt while remaining true to your core values.

Social and Cultural Impact

  • Community and Belonging:
    Identity is at the heart of social bonds. Shared identities, whether based on culture, nationality, or shared experiences, create a sense of belonging and community. This collective identity can drive social movements and foster cultural enrichment.

  • Cultural Preservation:
    Understanding identity helps preserve cultural heritage and traditions. It allows communities to celebrate their uniqueness while engaging with the broader world.

  • Social Justice and Equity:
    Recognizing the multifaceted nature of identity is essential for addressing social inequalities. Intersectional approaches to identity can inform policies and initiatives aimed at promoting inclusion and fairness in society.

Economic and Professional Relevance

  • Workplace Diversity and Innovation:
    In the professional realm, a diverse range of identities contributes to creativity and innovation. Understanding identity helps organizations create inclusive environments where all employees can thrive.

  • Marketing and Consumer Behavior:
    Businesses that understand the identities of their target audiences can tailor their products, services, and messaging to better meet their needs. This leads to more effective marketing and stronger brand loyalty.

  • Global Collaboration:
    In a globalized world, recognizing and respecting diverse identities is essential for successful international cooperation and cross-cultural communication.

Benefits and Applications in Various Domains

In Education

  • Curriculum and Teaching:
    Integrating identity studies into the curriculum can help students develop critical thinking skills, empathy, and a deeper understanding of social dynamics. Subjects such as history, literature, and social studies often explore themes of identity, providing students with tools to understand themselves and others.

  • Extracurricular Activities:
    Programs that celebrate cultural diversity, such as multicultural clubs and language exchange programs, enrich students’ understanding of their own identities and those of their peers.

In Business and Organizational Settings

  • Diversity and Inclusion Initiatives:
    Organizations that actively address identity-related issues create more inclusive workplaces. Diversity training and inclusive hiring practices can lead to improved employee morale, productivity, and innovation.

  • Brand Identity:
    Companies build strong brand identities by aligning their values with those of their consumers. Understanding identity trends helps businesses develop marketing strategies that resonate with diverse audiences.

In Media and Communication

  • Storytelling and Representation:
    In literature, film, and journalism, identity is a central theme. Accurate and empathetic representations of diverse identities help shape public perceptions and foster social understanding.

  • Digital and Social Media:
    Online platforms offer new avenues for expressing and exploring identity. From personal blogs to social media profiles, digital identity plays a crucial role in shaping how we interact with the world.

In Public Policy and Governance

  • Inclusive Policy-Making:
    Recognizing the diverse identities within a population is essential for crafting policies that promote equality and justice. Governments that consider the multifaceted nature of identity are better equipped to address social disparities and foster a sense of community.

  • Transitional Justice and Reconciliation:
    In post-conflict societies, processes of reconciliation often hinge on recognizing and respecting the identities of all groups involved. These efforts are crucial for building lasting peace and fostering social cohesion.

For more on the importance of understanding identity, check out research articles on Identity Theory and studies from Pew Research Center.


Section 5: Common Misconceptions and FAQs About Identity

Debunking Common Misconceptions

Despite its complexity, several misconceptions about what is identity persist. Let’s address some of the most common myths:

  • Misconception #1: Identity Is Fixed and Unchanging.
    Reality:
    Identity is dynamic and constantly evolving. It is shaped by personal experiences, social interactions, and cultural influences over time.

  • Misconception #2: Identity Is Solely a Personal Matter.
    Reality:
    While personal identity is important, identity is also deeply social. How we perceive ourselves is intertwined with how others see us, and cultural, national, and social identities play crucial roles.

  • Misconception #3: One Aspect of Identity Defines the Whole Person.
    Reality:
    Identity is multifaceted and includes various dimensions such as race, gender, religion, and personal interests. No single aspect can capture the full complexity of who we are.

  • Misconception #4: Digital Identity Is Separate from Real-Life Identity.
    Reality:
    While digital identity can be curated and sometimes differ from one’s offline self, it is an integral part of modern identity formation. Our online personas interact with and influence our overall sense of self.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  • Q: What is identity?
    A: Identity is the unique combination of characteristics, experiences, values, and social affiliations that define who we are as individuals and groups. It encompasses both our internal self-concept and how we are perceived by others.

  • Q: Why is identity important?
    A: Identity shapes our behaviors, decisions, and interactions. It influences our self-esteem, our relationships, and our roles within society. Understanding identity is crucial for personal growth, social cohesion, and effective communication.

  • Q: How is identity formed?
    A: Identity is formed through a complex interplay of genetic, personal, cultural, and social factors. Life experiences, education, and social interactions all contribute to shaping who we are.

  • Q: Can identity change over time?
    A: Yes. Identity is dynamic and evolves as we encounter new experiences, form new relationships, and adapt to changing social and cultural contexts.

  • Q: How does digital identity factor into overall identity?
    A: Digital identity, created through online interactions and social media, is a modern extension of our overall identity. It reflects both our personal characteristics and our engagement with the broader digital community.


Section 6: Modern Relevance and Current Trends in Identity

Identity in the Digital Age

In today’s interconnected world, what is identity has taken on new dimensions. Digital technology has transformed the way we express and perceive identity, creating both opportunities and challenges.

Digital and Social Media Influence

  • Online Personas:
    Social media platforms allow individuals to craft and curate their digital identities. These online personas can reflect, exaggerate, or even diverge from one’s offline self.

  • Global Connectivity:
    The digital age has enabled cross-cultural interactions that enrich our understanding of identity. Exposure to diverse perspectives fosters a more fluid and dynamic concept of self.

  • Privacy and Authenticity:
    With digital identity comes the challenge of maintaining privacy while striving for authenticity. Balancing these aspects is a key issue in modern identity formation.

The Role of Identity in Politics and Social Movements

  • Identity Politics:
    Identity has become a central focus in contemporary politics, with social movements often mobilizing around shared aspects of identity such as race, gender, and nationality. These movements aim to address historical injustices and promote social equality.

  • Cultural Representation:
    In media and art, representation matters. Diverse portrayals of identity in films, literature, and visual arts are influencing public perceptions and contributing to broader social change.

Research and Academic Trends

  • Interdisciplinary Approaches:
    Scholars are increasingly examining identity through interdisciplinary lenses, incorporating insights from psychology, sociology, anthropology, and digital studies. This holistic approach enriches our understanding of how identity is constructed and expressed.

  • Impact of Globalization:
    Globalization has blurred the boundaries of national and cultural identity, leading to hybrid identities that incorporate elements from multiple cultures. This trend challenges traditional notions of identity and encourages more fluid, inclusive definitions.

For more current insights on identity, resources like the Pew Research Center and academic journals such as Identity: An International Journal of Theory and Research provide valuable perspectives.


Section 7: Practical Applications and Benefits of Understanding Identity

Everyday Benefits and Personal Empowerment

Understanding what is identity can profoundly impact your personal and professional life:

  • Enhanced Self-Awareness:
    By reflecting on your own identity, you gain a clearer sense of who you are, your values, and your goals. This self-awareness is crucial for personal growth and informed decision-making.

  • Improved Communication:
    Recognizing the diverse aspects of identity helps you communicate more effectively with others, fostering empathy and understanding in both personal and professional interactions.

  • Strengthened Relationships:
    An awareness of identity, both your own and others’, can lead to healthier, more respectful relationships. It promotes acceptance and reduces conflict arising from misunderstandings.

  • Informed Social and Political Engagement:
    Understanding the complexities of identity is vital for engaging in social and political discourse. It empowers you to advocate for policies and practices that promote inclusion and equity.

Applications Across Various Domains

In Education

  • Curriculum Integration:
    Incorporating identity studies into educational curricula helps students develop critical thinking and cultural awareness. Lessons on identity can explore topics like diversity, multiculturalism, and self-expression.

  • Interactive Workshops:
    Workshops and seminars on identity can encourage students to share their own experiences and engage in dialogues that foster mutual understanding and respect.

In Business and Professional Environments

  • Diversity and Inclusion Programs:
    Organizations that understand the importance of identity are better equipped to implement effective diversity and inclusion initiatives. This leads to more innovative and harmonious workplaces.

  • Brand Identity and Marketing:
    Companies use identity as a cornerstone of their brand strategy. A strong, authentic brand identity can resonate with consumers, build loyalty, and differentiate a business in a competitive market.

In Media and Communication

  • Representation and Storytelling:
    In literature, film, and journalism, the portrayal of diverse identities enriches the narrative and reflects the true diversity of society. Effective storytelling that considers identity can influence public opinion and drive social change.

  • Digital Content Creation:
    Understanding identity is crucial for crafting engaging digital content. Whether you’re developing a blog, a social media campaign, or a documentary, a nuanced view of identity enhances authenticity and relatability.

In Public Policy and Social Justice

  • Inclusive Policy-Making:
    Policymakers who consider the complexities of identity are better able to address social inequities. Policies that promote inclusivity, respect cultural diversity, and protect individual rights are essential for a fair society.

  • Conflict Resolution and Reconciliation:
    In communities experiencing social or ethnic tensions, understanding identity is a key component of reconciliation efforts. Recognizing and respecting diverse identities can pave the way for dialogue and healing.

For additional practical insights on leveraging identity for personal and societal benefit, resources like The Greater Good Science Center and Harvard Business Review offer valuable articles and case studies.


Section 8: Conclusion and Call-to-Action

Summarizing the Essentials

So, what is identity? Identity is the unique combination of personal characteristics, social roles, cultural influences, and experiences that define who we are. It is a dynamic and multifaceted concept that shapes our interactions, influences our decisions, and underpins our sense of belonging. Throughout this guide, we have:

  • Provided a clear definition of identity, highlighting its internal and external components.
  • Explored the essential characteristics of identity, including its multidimensional, evolving, and culturally influenced nature.
  • Traced the historical evolution of identity from ancient philosophical inquiries to modern theories and digital transformations.
  • Delved into an in-depth exploration of different types of identity—personal, social, cultural, and digital—and examined how they intersect and influence one another.
  • Presented real-world examples and case studies that illustrate how identity manifests in various contexts, from literature and media to business and public policy.
  • Highlighted the importance, applications, and benefits of understanding identity for personal empowerment, social cohesion, and economic development.
  • Addressed common misconceptions and FAQs to clarify what identity is and dispel myths about its nature.
  • Discussed the modern relevance and current trends in identity, especially in the context of globalization and digital communication.

The Importance of Understanding Identity

Understanding what is identity is essential for both personal development and societal progress. It equips you with the tools to:

  • Develop a deeper self-awareness and make decisions that align with your true values.
  • Communicate effectively and build stronger, more empathetic relationships.
  • Engage in social and political processes with a nuanced understanding of cultural diversity and inclusion.
  • Navigate the complexities of the digital age, where online and offline identities often intersect and influence each other.

Call-to-Action

Now that you have a comprehensive understanding of identity, here are some steps you can take to further engage with this important topic:

  • Educate Yourself Further:
    Explore additional books, articles, and documentaries on identity. Notable works include “The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life” by Erving Goffman and “Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment” by Francis Fukuyama.

  • Reflect on Your Own Identity:
    Take time to reflect on your personal experiences, values, and social roles. Consider journaling about your journey of self-discovery and how various aspects of your identity have evolved over time.

  • Engage in Conversations:
    Join discussions, forums, or local groups that focus on topics of identity and diversity. Sharing your experiences and hearing others’ perspectives can broaden your understanding and foster mutual respect.

  • Advocate for Inclusion:
    Support initiatives and policies that promote diversity and inclusivity in your community, workplace, and beyond. Your voice can help create environments where all identities are respected and valued.

  • Share This Guide:
    If you found this post informative, please share it on social media, with your colleagues, and with anyone interested in deepening their understanding of identity. Spreading awareness about what is identity can contribute to a more empathetic and inclusive society.

  • Subscribe for More:
    Stay updated on the latest research, trends, and discussions related to identity by subscribing to our newsletter. Join our community of lifelong learners committed to exploring the complexities of human identity and social dynamics.

By taking these steps, you not only enhance your own understanding but also contribute to a broader conversation about identity that can drive positive change in your community and beyond.


Final Thoughts

Identity is far more than a label—it is the intricate tapestry of our experiences, relationships, and cultural influences that shapes who we are. Whether you are exploring your own sense of self or engaging in discussions about diversity and inclusion on a global scale, understanding what is identity is essential. It empowers you to navigate the complexities of modern life, build meaningful connections, and contribute to a more inclusive, empathetic world.

Thank you for taking the time to explore this comprehensive guide on identity. We hope it has provided you with valuable insights and practical knowledge that will inspire you to further explore and celebrate the rich diversity of human identity. As you continue your journey of self-discovery and engagement with the world around you, remember that every aspect of your identity contributes to the unique story that is you.

For further reading and additional resources on identity, please visit:

If you found this guide helpful, please share it on social media, leave your feedback in the comments below, and subscribe to our newsletter for more in-depth articles on psychology, culture, and social studies.

Let’s embrace the complexity of our identities and work together to create a more inclusive and understanding world—one conversation at a time.

Happy learning and self-discovery!


Leave a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *