ACT English: Production of Writing – Topic Development

Overview: What is Topic Development?

Topic development questions are a critical part of the Production of Writing section on the ACT English test. These questions assess your ability to analyze a writer’s rhetorical choices and determine whether they effectively communicate the intended theme or develop the topic. If you’ve taken courses like AP English Language and Composition or have studied for the SAT English section, the concept of rhetorical analysis will likely be familiar. Essentially, these questions ask you to evaluate whether the writer is adequately conveying their message and developing their topic in a coherent, purposeful way.

While topic development questions might seem daunting at first, they follow a recognizable pattern. Once you break them down into their main components—identifying the purpose of a text (or parts of it), assessing whether the text achieves its intended goal, and determining its relevance—you’ll find that these questions are manageable and even predictable.

Concepts to Know

Let’s take a closer look at the three main components you need to master for topic development: Purpose, Intended Goal, and Relevance. Understanding these concepts is essential for success in this section of the ACT.

Purpose

A text’s purpose is the reason why the author is writing it. This can usually be boiled down to a single verb, such as to inform, to persuade, or to entertain. Occasionally, you might encounter texts with more specific purposes, like to satirize, to discredit, or to explain.

• To inform: The primary goal is to educate the reader by providing information on a particular topic. Examples include scientific articles that present facts and evidence without bias.
• To persuade: The goal is to convince the reader of a particular viewpoint or to take action. Argumentative essays and opinion pieces often fall into this category.
• To entertain: The author’s aim is to provide enjoyment to the reader, often through storytelling, humor, or creative writing. Fictional stories, poems, and anecdotes are common examples.

To identify a text’s purpose, start by determining its main topic or thesis. Ask yourself questions like: What is the author trying to convey? What point is the author making about this topic? By answering these questions, you can pinpoint the purpose of the text.

Intended Goal

The intended goal is closely related to the purpose but focuses on how well the text stays on track with its central theme. Where the purpose is about what the author is trying to achieve, the intended goal looks at whether the text or a specific part of it effectively communicates that purpose. Is the writer staying focused on the main idea, or are they drifting into unrelated topics? This concept is essential for evaluating the coherence and unity of a passage.

Relevance

Relevance is all about ensuring that every part of the text contributes meaningfully to its overall purpose. It answers the “so what?” question in writing. Each piece of information should support the author’s main argument or theme. When examining relevance, consider whether certain details add value to the text, if deleting a sentence would leave a gap in the argument, or if adding a sentence would enhance the reader’s understanding.

Relevance involves asking critical questions: Does this piece of information help the reader understand the main point? Would removing this sentence change the meaning of the text? Is the information provided in each paragraph consistent with the overall purpose? These are the kinds of questions you’ll need to answer when tackling relevance questions.

Tips and Tricks

1. Master Grammar Basics

Knowing your basic grammar rules is essential not just for Topic Development but for the entire ACT English test. This knowledge is the foundation you’ll apply when analyzing texts and assessing whether they effectively develop their topics. If you’re not confident in your grammar skills, it’s important to start with the basics and gradually work up to more complex concepts. This approach will help you feel more prepared and capable of tackling these questions.

2. Understand Structure

A deep understanding of structure is crucial when analyzing texts. A well-structured text allows the writer to communicate their intent clearly and makes it easier for the reader to follow the flow of ideas. Conversely, a poorly structured text is often harder to understand and may contain irrelevant information.

Key elements of structure include the thesis, paragraph types, sentence placement, and overall cohesion. Recognizing these elements will help you identify texts that lack a clear message and determine whether they fulfill their intended purpose. Remember, sometimes the best answer is “NO CHANGE” if the passage is already well-organized and effective.

3. Practice Active Reading

Active reading is a valuable strategy, especially when dealing with less engaging texts, which you’ll likely encounter on the ACT. To avoid zoning out, engage with the text as you read. Different strategies work for different people—some might find it helpful to underline or highlight key points, while others might prefer making annotations or marking significant sections with symbols.

Active reading ensures that you stay focused and retain more information, which is crucial when answering questions about topic development. The more engaged you are with the text, the easier it will be to analyze its structure and relevance.

4. Develop a Strategy

Effective reading also involves strategic question answering. How you approach these questions depends on what works best for you. Some students find it helpful to read the questions before reading the passage, so they know what to look for. Others prefer to answer questions that refer to specific lines or sections first.

Another strategy is to decide how you’ll go through the questions: will you tackle them one by one, or will you group similar types together? Developing a strategy that suits your learning style can save you time and increase your accuracy on the test.

5. Practice Regularly

Practice is the key to success on the ACT. The more you practice, the more familiar you’ll become with the types of questions you’ll face, and the more confident you’ll feel in your abilities. Regular practice helps reinforce the skills you need to analyze texts effectively and develop a strong understanding of topic development.

Example Questions

Let’s look at some example questions to see how these concepts apply in practice.

Example: Purpose

Purpose questions often provide the writer’s main purpose and ask whether the text accomplishes that purpose. For instance, consider the following scenario:

Example Question: The author’s primary purpose in this passage is to explain the process of making handmade pottery. Does the passage successfully achieve this purpose?

• A. Yes, the passage provides a detailed, step-by-step guide to making pottery by hand.
• B. Yes, the passage briefly mentions the process but focuses more on the history of pottery.
• C. No, the passage fails to explain the process and instead discusses the author’s personal experiences with pottery.
• D. No, the passage provides information on different types of pottery but does not explain the process.

Explanation: To answer this question, recall what you determined the passage’s purpose to be after your initial reading. If your understanding was that the passage aimed to explain the pottery-making process, then Option A would be the correct choice. If the passage focused more on history or personal experiences, then A would not be correct. Always align your answer with the main points the text discusses.

Example: Intended Goal

Before determining whether a text meets its intended goal, you must first identify its purpose. Only then can you assess whether the passage or a portion of it effectively achieves that goal.

Example Question: Which of the following sentences best achieves the intended goal of introducing the benefits of organic farming in the passage?

• A. Organic farming has been practiced for centuries, dating back to early civilizations.
• B. The rise of organic farming has led to significant health benefits for consumers.
• C. Many farmers are turning to organic methods due to environmental concerns.
• D. Organic farming is a complex process that requires significant knowledge and skill.

Explanation: To determine the correct answer, first consider the purpose of the paragraph. If the paragraph is meant to introduce the benefits of organic farming, Option B would be the best choice, as it directly addresses health benefits. The other options may be relevant in different contexts but do not directly introduce the benefits as effectively.

Example: Relevance

Relevance questions require you to assess whether certain information adds value to the passage or if it should be removed to improve clarity and focus.

Example Question: The passage discusses the history of public libraries. Which of the following sentences should be deleted because it is least relevant to this discussion?

• A. “Public libraries have been an essential part of communities for centuries.”
• B. “Many modern libraries offer digital resources in addition to traditional books.”
• C. “The first public library in the United States was established in 1833 in Peterborough, New Hampshire.”
• D. “Public libraries often host events such as author readings and community workshops.”

Explanation: In this example, Option B introduces information about modern libraries, which may not be directly relevant to a discussion focused on the history of public libraries. Therefore, this sentence should be considered for deletion to maintain the passage’s focus on historical context.

TLDR: Your ACT English – Topic Development Checklist

Topic development is a type of question you’ll encounter in the ACT English section that evaluates a passage’s purpose, intended goal, and relevance. Here’s a quick checklist to ensure you’re prepared:

• Do you know your basic grammar rules? Solid grammar knowledge is essential for understanding and evaluating passages.
• Do you understand structure? Recognizing and analyzing the structure of a text will help you determine its effectiveness.
• Do you understand what the text is saying? Active reading and comprehension are crucial for answering topic development questions.
• Do you have a strategy for approaching a text and its questions? Develop a method that works for you to maximize efficiency and accuracy.
• Do you know how to identify purpose? Pinpointing the author’s purpose is the first step in evaluating the text’s effectiveness.
• Do you know how to determine whether or not a text achieves its intended goal? Assess if the text stays focused on its main theme.
• Is every part of the text you are examining relevant to its purpose? Evaluate the relevance of each sentence or paragraph to the overall passage.
• Finally, have you practiced, and do you feel confident about this subject? Regular practice is the key to mastering topic development questions.

By following this checklist and applying these strategies, you’ll be well-prepared to tackle topic development questions on the ACT English section with confidence.

NUMBERS is proud of you. 

© NUMBERS. All rights reserved.

AP® and SAT ® are trademarks registered by the College Board.  College Board is not affiliated with nor endorses this website.